If Your Child Doesn't Know It's Broken, You Can't Fix It: The First Step to Better Executive Functioning

Before we can teach the skills, children need to see the need.
As a counsellor, I often meet parents who have a long list of things they would like their child to improve: getting started on assignments, managing time, staying organized, remembering deadlines, and becoming more independent.
And often, they're absolutely right.

But there's one important question I like to explore first:
Does their child actually see these things as a problem?
If a child doesn't recognize that their current approach isn't working, it's difficult to create meaningful change. Parents may be highly motivated to see improvement, but external motivation alone rarely leads to lasting change. When it comes to developing executive functioning skills, awareness is often the missing first step.
Motivation has to become theirs.
In my work as a counsellor, I use a CBT-informed approach to explore the relationship between thoughts, feelings and behaviours.
Much like working with a child who experiences anxiety, we first need to understand what's getting in the way. Is the child worried about making mistakes? Overwhelmed by the size of an assignment? Afraid they won't succeed? Or simply unsure where to begin?
Sometimes, avoidance is connected to uncomfortable emotions and negative thoughts. Before introducing organizational strategies or executive functioning tools, we may need to help the child recognize these patterns, develop emotional regulation skills and challenge unhelpful thinking.
Once a child identifies something they personally want to change, we can begin setting small, realistic and measurable goals.
The shift we're looking for is from "My parents want me to do this" to "I can see why this would make my life easier."
That's when the real work can begin.
A common pattern: When perfectionism gets in the way.
I often work with young clients who struggle with task initiation. Instead of starting
homework or other responsibilities, they find themselves on screens, doing chores, or tackling just about anything else. While ADHD or executive functioning challenges can certainly contribute to these difficulties, perfectionism is sometimes a significant part of what is getting in the way.
For some, the fear that their work won't be good enough makes getting started feel
almost impossible. They may procrastinate, avoid tasks, or spend excessive time trying to get things just right.
In sessions, we explore and challenge the thoughts behind this need for perfection, helping
to develop a more realistic and flexible way of thinking about their work.
But the real change happens between sessions. Clients are encouraged to practise
completing tasks ish-ly—not perfectly. The goal is to show themselves that nothing terrible
happens when their work isn't flawless.
Sometimes, the biggest step forward isn't learning how to do something better. It's learning that it's okay not to do it perfectly. This is an important part of executive functioning coaching: sometimes the barrier isn't a lack of strategies or skills, but the thoughts and feelings that prevent a child from using them.
How parents can build independence at home.

Parents play an incredibly important role in helping children develop executive functioning skills. But sometimes, the most helpful thing we can do is change how we communicate.
1. Model your thinking out loud.
Children don't automatically know how to plan, organize or problem-solve. They need to hear what these processes actually sound like.
Try narrating your own thinking:
"I'm feeling overwhelmed by all these errands, so I'm going to write a quick list and figure out what needs to happen first." Or, "I almost forgot my appointment tomorrow. I'm going to put it in my calendar right now."
These small moments help children see how adults approach everyday challenges. You're giving them a window into the thinking processes behind effective executive functioning.
2. Ask questions instead of giving directions.
Rather than constantly reminding children what to do, try using questions that encourage them to think for themselves.
Instead of: "Where is your jacket?"
Try: "What do you need to have with you before we walk out the door?"
Instead of: "Have you started your homework yet?"
Try: "What's your plan for getting started?"
The goal is to gradually move children from relying on adult reminders to developing their own self-monitoring skills.
3. Connect before you correct.
When children struggle with organization, planning or getting started, it's easy for conversations to become frustrating.
Try approaching the situation from a same-team perspective rather than one of criticism.
"I can see this assignment feels overwhelming. Let's figure out what might help."
Connection creates an opportunity for problem-solving. Criticism often creates defensiveness.
Before we can expect children to work on their executive functioning, we need to create an environment where they feel supported enough to recognize their challenges and try something different.
4. Allow room for mistakes.
Not every forgotten item or missed step needs to become a teaching moment delivered by a parent.
When it's safe and appropriate, allow children to experience minor natural consequences. Forgetting a non-essential item or realizing they haven't left enough time to complete a task can provide valuable opportunities to problem-solve.
The goal isn't to rescue children from every uncomfortable experience. It's to help them learn from those experiences while knowing they have your support.
5. Let older children and teens have a say.
If you're working with a teenager, involve them in choosing the tools they want to use.
Whether it's a planner, an app, a calendar or a simple checklist, the system needs to work for them. A beautifully organized planner that a teenager refuses to use isn't particularly helpful!
Ownership matters. The more involved children are in choosing their own executive functioning strategies, the more likely they are to use them.
6. Remember that progress takes time.
Executive functioning skills develop gradually. There will be setbacks, forgotten assignments and moments when old habits resurface.
Try to see these moments as information rather than failures. What got in the way? What could we try differently next time?
And if executive functioning challenges are significantly affecting your child's learning, daily life or emotional well-being despite support at home, consider reaching out to their teacher, pediatrician, or a psychologist for additional guidance.
The ultimate goal: Independence, not perfection.
We don't want children who can manage their responsibilities only because someone is constantly reminding, prompting and organizing for them.
We want children who understand themselves, recognize what gets in their way, know which strategies help and gradually take ownership of their responsibilities.
The goal isn't for parents to work harder at managing their child's executive functioning. It's to help children develop the awareness and skills to manage more of it themselves.
As an Executive Functioning Coach, I believe meaningful progress starts with helping children understand themselves before expecting them to change their behaviour.
And it starts with a simple idea: If your child doesn't know it's broken, you can't fix it.
Melissa Kaye, MC, RCC| Registered Clinical Counsellor | North Shore CBT Centre
Melissa accepts referrals for counselling and executive functioning support.
Click here for her bio.